June 10, 2025 · 1:54 am

↓ Jump to Comments

Square Root Puzzle

Is it possible to find three numbers, $a, b, c$ , none of which is zero or a perfect square, such that
$\sqrt{a}+\sqrt{b}=\sqrt{c}$

Can You Solve These – David Wells

As $a, b$ and $c$ can’t be perfect squares, let $a=d\times e^2, b=f\times g^2$ and $c=h\times k^2$ where $d, e, f, g, h$ and $k$ are real numbers.

Hence $\sqrt{a}=e\sqrt{d}, \sqrt{b}=g\sqrt{f}$ and $\sqrt{c}=k\sqrt{h}$ .

$\begin{equation*}\sqrt{a}+\sqrt{b}=\sqrt{c}\end{equation}$

$\begin{equation*}e\sqrt{d}+g\sqrt{f}=k\sqrt{h}\end{equation}$

For the above equation to be possible $d, f$ and $h$ must simplify to the same surd. Because we are looking for one set of numbers, let $d=f=h$ .

$\begin{equation*}e\sqrt{d}+g\sqrt{d}=k\sqrt{d}\end{equation}$

$\begin{equation*}e+g=k\end{equation}$

Let’s think of some numbers that might work…

$1+2=3$ or $2+3=5$ , etc.

Let’s try $e=1, g=2,$ and $k=3$

We now have $a=d, b=4d,$ and $c=9d$

As $a$ can’t be a square number, $d$ can’t be a square number.

Try $d=2$

$\begin{equation*}\sqrt{2}+\sqrt{8}=\sqrt{18}\end{equation}$

$LHS=\sqrt{2}+2\sqrt{2}$

$LHS=3\sqrt{2}$

$LHS=\sqrt{9\times 2}$

$LHS=\sqrt{18}$

$LHS=RHS$

One set of possible numbers are $2, 8,$ and $18$ .

Leave a Comment

Filed under Algebra, Interesting Mathematics, Puzzles

Leave a Reply Cancel reply